Every artist eventually runs the same mental math... would I rather keep less of more sales or all of fewer sales, and almost nobody has the actual numbers in front of them when they do it, they are just going off vibes and one story they heard about a friend's gallery experience.

Yes, meaningfully, and it is worth knowing the range before agreeing to anything. Gallery commissions typically run 30 to 60 percent, and the specific number tells you something about the deal you are getting: 30 percent is on the artist-friendly end, 40 percent is a commonly cited fair split, 50 percent is standard in a lot of traditional gallery relationships, and 60 percent tends to sit at the gallery-heavy end, usually attached to significant marketing investment, a strong physical space, or serious institutional connections that genuinely justify the larger cut. Online consignment platforms typically take a lighter 15 to 30 percent (Saatchi Art takes 35%), since they are not covering physical space or in-person staffing the way a brick-and-mortar gallery is. It's worth knowing specifically if you are comparing an online platform's cut against a physical gallery's cut and feeling like the gallery number seems high in isolation, it usually is not once you account for what the gallery is actually covering.

What does selling directly actually cost, if not a commission?

You keep 100 percent of the sale price, and you also absorb everything a gallery would have otherwise handled: finding the buyer, presenting the work in a compelling space, negotiating the sale, handling logistics and shipping, and building the relationships that generate repeat collectors in the first place. But he part that gets glossed over in most "just sell directly and keep it all" advice, the labor does not vanish, it just stops being someone else's job. None of that work disappears when you sell direct, it just moves onto your own plate, which is real, ongoing labor that a commission percentage was quietly paying someone else to do.

So which one is actually better?

Neither, in the abstract, and the your answer depends entirely on what a specific gallery is actually doing for that commission. For instance, you paid 50 percent to a gallery for years and initially resented the cut, until you actually calculated the hours you would have spent finding buyers, hosting a physical space, and building the exact collector relationships the gallery had already built over a decade, and realized the math genuinely worked in you favor at that specific stage of your career. Compare that to an artist paying the same 50 percent to a gallery that rarely sells their work, barely promotes it, and provides none of the collector access that would justify the cut, where the same percentage represents a genuinely bad deal.

Look at what you are actually getting in exchange for the percentage: real foot traffic and a genuine physical audience, an existing collector base the gallery actively introduces you to, marketing and PR the gallery is actually doing, and sales volume that would be difficult to replicate on your own. If a gallery is taking 50 percent and providing little beyond wall space, that is a different arrangement than a gallery taking the same percentage while actively selling your work to collectors you would never have reached alone.

Quick version

  • Gallery commissions typically run 30-60%, with the specific percentage often reflecting the gallery's actual marketing investment and reach.
  • Online consignment platforms typically take a lighter 15-30%.
  • Selling direct keeps 100% of the price, but shifts all the marketing, sales, and logistics labor onto you.
  • Neither option is universally better, the real question is what you are actually getting in exchange for the commission a specific gallery takes.
  • Evaluate any gallery relationship by what it actually delivers, foot traffic, collector access, active promotion, not just the percentage on paper.

The commission was never really the whole story. What it is actually paying for is. (If you are also weighing where to sell in the first place, in-person or online factors into this too, more on that in local market vs. online reach.)